And the Runner-Up Is

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 39th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest to discuss women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Sebastian Gronback about two horror performances that were not nominated at the Oscars: Sheryl Lee ("Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me") and Jennifer Lawrence ("mother!").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they weren't nominated, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me" - New Line Cinema

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 38th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest to discuss women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Kenzie Vanunu about two performances nominated at the SAG Awards but not the Oscars: Evan Rachel Wood ("Thirteen") and Kate Winslet ("Revolutionary Road").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they weren't nominated, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Thirteen" - Fox Searchlight Pictures

This week on And the Runner-Up Is, Kevin welcomes writer Brandon Lewis to talk about Ryan Coogler's "Sinners," the presumed runner-up in the 2025 Best Picture race that lost to "One Battle After Another." We also discuss all other Best Picture nominees and which film we think deserved to win the Oscar.

0:00 - 10:00 - Introduction

10:01 - 1:11:03 - "Sinners" review

1:11:04 - 1:52:04 - Why "Sinners" lost Best Picture / Why "One Battle After Another" won

1:52:05 - 3:08:15 - Assessing the other eight Best Picture nominees

3:08:16 - 3:14:09 - Shoulda been a contender

3:14:10 - 3:18:35 - Did "Sinners" deserve to win?

Buy And the Runner-Up Is merch at https://www.teepublic.com/stores/and-the-runner-up-is?ref_id=24261!

Support And the Runner-Up Is on Patreon at patreon.com/andtherunnerupis!

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter and Instagram

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Artwork: Brian O'Meara

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 37th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with John T about two women co-leads who weren't nominated for Oscars: Audrey Hepburn and Shirley MacLaine in "The Children's Hour."

We discuss their performances, talk about why they weren't nominated, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"The Children's Hour" - United Artists

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 36th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Josh Parham about two performances nominated at the AARP Movies for Grownups Awards that weren't nominated for Oscars: Viola Davis ("Widows") and Alfre Woodard ("Clemency").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they weren't nominated, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Widows" - 20th Century Fox

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 35th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Izzy of Be Kind Rewind about two performances from LGBTQ+ actresses that weren't nominated for Oscars: Marlene Dietrich ("Witness for the Prosecution") and Anna Paquin ("Margaret").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they weren't nominated, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Witness for the Prosecution" - United Artists

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 34th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Brandon Stanwyck about two Best Actress-winning performances at the Cannes Film Festival that weren't nominated for Oscars: Isabelle Adjani ("Possession") and Julianne Moore ("Maps to the Stars").

We discuss their performances, talk about what would've happened if they were eligible, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Possession" - Metrograph Pictures

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 33rd episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Chelsea Eichholz about two performances from TV movies that weren't eligible for Oscars: Halle Berry ("Introducing Dorothy Dandridge") and Drew Barrymore ("Grey Gardens").

We discuss their performances, talk about what would've happened if they were eligible, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Introducing Dorothy Dandridge" - HBO

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 32nd episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Ema Sasic about two performances from films directed by women that weren't nominated at the Oscars: Danielle Deadwyler ("Till") and Margot Robbie ("Barbie").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they came up short, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Till" - United Artists Releasing

This week on And the Runner-Up Is, Kevin welcomes back Oscar Wild cohost Nick Ruhrkraut to discuss the 2025 Oscar race for Best Actress, where Jessie Buckley won for her performance in "Hamnet," beating Rose Byrne in "If I Had Legs I'd Kick You," Kate Hudson in "Song Sung Blue," Renate Reinsve in "Sentimental Value," and Emma Stone in "Bugonia." We discuss all of these nominated performances and determine who we think was the runner-up to Buckley.

0:00 - 10:34 - Introduction

10:35 - 39:08 - Rose Byrne

39:09 - 1:12:00 - Kate Hudson

1:12:01 - 1:46:30 - Renate Reinsve

1:46:31 - 2:14:21 - Emma Stone

2:14:22 - 2:45:05 - Jessie Buckley

2:45:06 - 3:34:04 - Why Jessie Buckley won / listener questions

3:34:05 - 3:37:48 - Who was the runner-up?

Buy And the Runner-Up Is merch at https://www.teepublic.com/stores/and-the-runner-up-is?ref_id=24261!

Support And the Runner-Up Is on Patreon at patreon.com/andtherunnerupis!

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter, Instagram, and Bluesky

Theme/End Music: "Diamonds" by Iouri Sazonov

Additional Music: "Storming Cinema Ident" by Edward Blakeley

Artwork: Brian O'Meara

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 31st episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Morgan Roberts about two performances that weren't nominated for this year's Oscars: Chase Infiniti ("One Battle After Another") and Amanda Seyfried ("The Testament of Ann Lee").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they came up short, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"One Battle After Another" - Warner Bros.

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 30th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Lauren LaMagna about two performances from sci-fi films that weren't nominated for Oscars: Linda Hamilton ("Terminator 2: Judgment Day") and Charlize Theron ("Mad Max: Fury Road").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they came up short, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Terminator 2: Judgment Day" - TriStar Pictures

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 29th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Sophia Ciminello about two past performances from current Oscar-contending actresses: Renate Reinsve ("The Worst Person in the World") and Tessa Thompson ("Passing").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they came up short, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"The Worst Person in the World" - NEON

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 28th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Dan Bayer about two performances from musicals that didn't earn Oscar nominations: Björk ("Dancer in the Dark") and Amy Adams ("Enchanted").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they came up short, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Dancer in the Dark" - Fine Line Pictures

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 27th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Andrew Carden about two performances from movies we love to watch in the fall season that didn't earn Oscar nominations: Mia Farrow ("Hannah and Her Sisters") and Meryl Streep ("Death Becomes Her").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they came up short, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Hannah and Her Sisters" - Orion Pictures

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 26th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Chris Feil about two performances recognized at the Razzies that didn't deserve to be: Shelley Duvall ("The Shining") and Elizabeth Berkley ("Showgirls").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they came up short, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"The Shining" - Warner Bros.

This week on And the Runner-Up Is, Kevin welcomes writer/editor Daniel Montgomery to talk about Edward Berger's "Conclave," the presumed runner-up in the 2024 Best Picture race that lost to "Anora." We also discuss all other Best Picture nominees and which film we think deserved to win the Oscar.

0:00 - 5:51 - Introduction

5:51 - 41:45 - "Conclave" review

41:46 - 1:06:52 - Why "Conclave" lost Best Picture / Why "Anora" won

1:06:53 - 2:31:23 - Assessing the other eight Best Picture nominees

2:31:24 - 2:36:31 - Shoulda been a contender

2:36:32 - 2:41:10 - Did "Conclave" deserve to win?

Buy And the Runner-Up Is merch at https://www.teepublic.com/stores/and-the-runner-up-is?ref_id=24261!

Support And the Runner-Up Is on Patreon at patreon.com/andtherunnerupis!

Follow And the Runner-Up Is on Twitter and Instagram

Theme/End Music is "The Virtue" by Jonathan Adamich

Artwork: Brian O'Meara

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 25th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Mattie Lucas about two Best Actress Oscar winners who were overlooked for a leading performance earlier in their careers: Julianne Moore ("Safe") and Reese Witherspoon ("Election").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they came up short, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Safe" - Sony Pictures Classics

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 24th episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Chelsea Eichholz about two Best Supporting Actress Oscar winners who were overlooked for a leading performance: Geena Davis ("A League of Their Own") and Whoopi Goldberg ("Sister Act").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they came up short, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $5 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"A League of Their Own" - Columbia Pictures

Listen to this PREVIEW of the 23rd episode of A Woman Robbed, a special bonus series you can hear on the And the Runner-Up Is Patreon exclusive feed!

A Woman Robbed is a series in which Kevin is joined by a special guest in discussing women who had significant Oscar buzz heading into the nominations but were ultimately robbed/snubbed/omitted from the Best Actress lineup. In this episode, Kevin speaks with Eoin Daly about two performances from women-led ensemble films that weren't nominated for Best Actress at the Oscars: Sally Field ("Steel Magnolias") and Kristen Wiig ("Bridesmaids").

We discuss their performances, talk about why they came up short, and reveal whether we would have nominated them.

You can listen to the full episode of A Woman Robbed by going to https://www.patreon.com/andtherunnerupis and contributing at the $3 per month tier.

Clips included in this episode:

"Steel Magnolias" - Tri-Star Pictures