Podcast
Caught Lookin’: A Cleveland Guardians Podcast
Caught Lookin’ is a Cleveland Guardians focused baseball podcast hosted by a rotating crew of female fans who love the game — and love talking about it. Each week we break down the latest from the corner of Carnegie and Ontario: game highlights, player moments, fan culture, merch, ballpark vibes, and the chaos in between. This show centers voices that are too often sidelined in sports talk. No guys behind the mic — just smart, funny, passionate people bringing a fresh perspective to Cleveland baseball. Whether you’re here for the hot takes, heartbreaks, or home runs — don’t get caught lookin’!
- Episodes
- 59
- Releases
- Weekly
- Typical length
- 58 min
- On air since
- 2025
- Latest episode
- 1 week ago
Episodes
59 episodes, newest first
-
1 hr 5 min
It’s the Hope That Kills You
Season 2, Episode 42
Show notes
This week on Caught Lookin', Kelsey, Sarah, and Molly perform a postmortem on the Guardians season as a whole and look forward to the year ahead of us in 2027. The ladies talk trades, position changes, and the upcoming Cavs season with Donovan Mitchell at the helm!
-
57 min
We're Also Little Fellas, Just Like Them
Season 2, Episode 41
Show notes
This week on Caught Lookin', Meg, Mikayla, and Madelyn lament the last two losses and try to stay positive about Game 6 (and Game 7!). Mikayla also gives us an update on the newest baseball card products to keep an eye out for!
-
1 hr 4 min
Teams of Destiny (and the Dodgers)
Season 2, Episode 40
Show notes
On this weeks episode of Caught Lookin', Kelsey, Sarah and Ali recount the miraculous Guardians comeback in the ALDS against the Chicago White Sox and the heroics of Gavin Williams and José Ramírez. The ladies discuss the upcoming matchups and stats for the ALCS against the Tampa Bay Rays!
-
58 min
He's a Psycho, Said With Love
Season 2, Episode 39
Show notes
In this latest episode of Caught Lookin', Meg, Molly, Nicole, Ash, and surprise! Ali chat game 1 of the ALDS against the White Sox: what went wrong, what went right, and how we can win game 2 and the series.
-
53 min
I Want to Party with Matt Festa
Season 2, Episode 38
Show notes
Merry Clinchmas to all and to all a happy bye week! Meg, Mary, and Sarah celebrate the Guardians clinching their third AL Central title in a row, talk about who they were most impressed with this season, and more!
-
1 hr 1 min
(Maybe) He’s Born With It
Season 2, Episode 37
Show notes
On this weeks episode of Caught Lookin', Kelsey, Molly, and Ash dive deep into the potential playoff hopes for the Guards. They take a look at the current playoff picture across the league, the 5 game win streak for the Guards this week, and what the future matchups hold as we head to Boston!
-
59 min
Everyone’s A Utility Player
Season 2, Episode 36
Show notes
This week on Caught Lookin', Meg, Madelyn, and Mikayla welcome pitcher/catcher for the Women’s Professional Baseball League’s LA Queens — Jamie Mackay! The ladies chat WPBL playoffs, the excitement and challenges of the WPBL, hopes for the future of the league, and manage to squeeze in a little baseball card talk and Guards yapping.
-
1 hr 3 min
It’s All The AL Central? …Always Has Been
Season 2, Episode 35
Show notes
On this week's episode of Caught Lookin', Meg, Kelsey, Sarah, and Ash chat about the Guards recent win streak, who might be coming up on September 1st, more complaining about the MLB vs MLBPA contract proposals, and more.
Programming note: we will not have an episode next week but will be back the week of September 14th!
-
49 min
Jo Adell Saved My Life
Season 2, Episode 34
Show notes
On this week's episode of Caught Lookin', Kelsey, Jenell, Molly, and Sarah discuss the Guardians recents highs, taking 5 of 6 games this past week, how our Guards trade acquisitions are doing after settling in, and the current Wild Card race!
-
51 min
Petey Halpin: Himbo
Season 2, Episode 3
Show notes
This week on Caught Lookin', Meg is joined by Mary and Ali and the ladies lament about the sad state of the Cleveland Guardians. What's wrong with the vibes? Why can't we string together wins? What's going on?! And how are we still in the playoff race?
-
1 hr
I’ve Never Heard of That Man in My Life
Season 2, Episode 32
Show notes
This week on Caught Lookin', Kelsey, Ash, and Mikayla discuss a week of woes for the Guardians, as well as the trade acquisitions, who we lost, and Mikayla's time at the National Card Show!
-
59 min
A Whole Team of Bobby Bonillas
Season 2, Episode 31
Show notes
On this week's episode of Caught Lookin', Meg is joined by Sarah and Jenell and the ladies talk Skubal to the Dodgers, the bullpen implosion of this weekend, the surprising sturdiness of our starters, trade deadline, and more.
-
1 hr 4 min
We're All At Risk of Being at a Spirit Halloween
Season 2, Episode 30
Show notes
This week on Caught Lookin', Meg is joined by Nicole and Kelsey and the ladies welcome Liz as their next Across the Diamond guest! They talk Rays vs. Guards, why it might not be the worst thing in the world to be swept by the Rays this past weekend, and omg did you know that Junior Caminero was once in the Guards minor league system?!
-
46 min
The Rotting Corpse of Carlos Santana
Season 2, Episode 29
Show notes
This week Meg is joined by Sarah, Mikayla, and Madelyn and the ladies chat All Star Game, the Pirates series, muse over how the next weeks before the trade deadline will play out, and the return of Mikayla's Card Corner!
-
53 min
A Game of Death, Yet We Persist?
Season 2, Episode 28
Show notes
This week on Caught Lookin’, Kelsey is joined by Sarah, Ali and Mary as they discuss the Twins and Miami series before the All-Star break. They also give their grades for the first half of the season, discuss what the lineup might look like with the imminent return of Jose and Angel, and give their outlooks for the second half of the season.
-
54 min
Catcher Crop Top Catastrophe
Season 2, Episode 27
Show notes
This week on Caught Lookin', Meg, Nicole, Jenell, and Molly chat about the White Sox series, why we need to take it easy on Cooper Ingle, who might be the odd man out come the trade deadline, and more.
-
1 hr 6 min
One Day We Will Find Our Julio
Season 2, Episode 26
Show notes
This week on Caught Lookin', Meg, Nicole, and Mary are joined by Seattle Mariners fan, Shay, for an Across the Diamond episode. The ladies chat Shay's strange journey to being an Ohio-born Seattle fan, the woes both fan bases are enduring, and the Naylor/Hedges chirping from Sunday's game.
-
58 min
Steven Kwan If You Can Hear Us
Season 2, Episode 25
Show notes
This week, Kelsey, Ash, and Ali go on a deep dive of the current CBA negotiations happening between the MLB and the MLBPA. Kelsey explains the MLB's recent draft overhaul proposal as well as the first proposal from the MLBPA and a potential salary floor and cap. They discuss the Milwaukee and Houston series, and preview the upcoming AL Central battle with the Chicago White Sox.
-
56 min
You're Either a Little Sore or You're Dead
Season 2, Episode 24
Show notes
On this weeks episode of Caught Lookin', Meg is joined by Sarah, Ash, and Kelsey and the ladies scream into the void about the sudden rash of injuries the Guardians sustained in Saturday's game against the Tigers. What do the next couple of weeks look like? Who needs to step up? How long will José be out? What is the fate of the AL Central?
-
58 min
The Boys Have a Terrible Case of the Sunday Scaries
Season 2, Episode 23
Show notes
This week on Caught Lookin', Meg, Molly, and Madelyn chat about the past week in Guardians baseball — celebrating the Guards taking 2 of 3 from the Yankees and lamenting losing 2 of 3 to the Rangers, and looking forward to this next week against the Yankees (again?!) and the Tigers (will we be seeing Skubal?).
Baseball lists
More Baseball shows picked out from the charts
More in Baseball
Placed highest on Apple Podcasts' Baseball chart right now