Podcast
Once More With Feeling
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over...
New episodes every other Wednesday.
Follow us!
- Film Reviews chart
- #44
- Episodes
- 33
- Releases
- Every two weeks
- Typical length
- 1 hr 43 min
- On air since
- 2025
- Latest episode
- 1 week ago
Episodes
33 episodes, newest first
-
1 hr 36 min
Once More With The Worst Prom Of All Time - Carrie (1976 & 2013)
Season 2, Episode 8
Show notes
Mariana and Gus watched what is normally considered one of the best films of all time, and then also one of the films of all time, and then they talked about them. And yes, technically, this could describe almost every episode of this podcast, but here I'm talking about Carrie.
Also, Gus was real tired when recording so that's his bad and he promises to get more sleep in the future.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 45 min
Once More With Antarctic Alien-Based Paranoia - The Thing (1982 & 2011)
Season 2, Episode 7
Show notes
Mariana and Gus are back from their unplanned hiatus...or maybe it's their alien imposters!?!?! After watching The Thing (1982), they don't know what or who to believe!! Though after watching The Thing (2011), they're pretty sure they're not cliched slasher/monster movie enough to be lying about this.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 52 min
Once More With Zombies (and Malls) (feat. Chris Waves) - Dawn of the Dead (1978 & 2004)
Season 2, Episode 6
Show notes
Mariana and Gus are joined by Chris Waves to watch the movie that basically spawned modern zombies. Some may argue it was actually Night of the Living Dead that did that, but those people are wrong. It was Dawn of the Dead. If those people ask you to prove it, ask them which movie inspired Dead Rising.
Yeah, that's what I thought.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and improviser Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 43 min
Once More With Possessed Murder Dolls (feat. Nadia from WomanCarryingMan) - Child's Play (1988 & 2019)
Season 2, Episode 5
Show notes
Mariana and Gus are joined by the inexorable Nadia from WomanCarryingMan to discuss Child's Play, a movie that, fun fact, made Gus' mom stop watching horror movies forever and which also, fun fact, made Gus think maybe horror movies aren't so bad. They also watched and discuss Child's Play, a movie which made Gus think maybe horror movies are that bad again.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and improviser Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 1 min
Once More With Little Alien Children - Escape To/Race To Witch Mountain (1975 & 2009)
Season 1, Episode 25
Show notes
Mariana and Gus watched the first and the reboot of the Witch Mountain series, and--wait, what? It's a series? There are FIVE Witch Mountain movies? There was almost a Witch Mountain TV show? What's going on? What universe am I in? IS IT BERENSTEIN OR BERENSTAIN?
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and improviser Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 43 min
"They're Heeere" Once More (feat. Mikey of FilmJoy) - Poltergeist (1982 & 2015)
Season 2, Episode 4
Show notes
Mariana and Gus brought on a spooky ghost expert - Mikey from FilmJoy - to talk about all things Poltergeist and also about Poltergeist. Yes, Gus did completely forget to bring up the fact that Poltergeist 2015 was released in 3D, and yes, that would have made a hilarious tangent, and yes, that will haunt his dreams for the next week and a half.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and improviser Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 31 min
Once More With Unusual Days of the Week (feat. Kyle from Door Monster) - Freaky Friday (1977 & 2003)
Season 1, Episode 24
Show notes
Mariana and Gus are joined by the wonderful Kyle from Door Monster as they talk about Freaky Friday (1977), and then later they talk about Freaky Friday (2003). Did you know? Freaky Friday (2003) is actually an excellent film? It's not just your memory!
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 58 min
Once More With the BEEEES (feat. Dan Olson of Folding Ideas) - The Wicker Man (1973 & 2006)
Season 2, Episode 3
Show notes
Mariana and Gus welcome the preposterously prolific Dan Olson (Folding Ideas) to talk about one of the most important movies of the 1970s (The Wicker Man (1973)), colonialism, fascinating art, which capeslop is good capeslop, and what happens when American studios try to remake a film deeply tied to the cultural and historical context of its setting (spoilers: it's The Wicker Man (2006)).
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 18 min
Once More Back To The Water - Moana (2016 & 2026)
Season 1, Episode 23
Show notes
Look. Statistically, you saw the original movie. Statistically, you did not see the remake. Well, we watched both. Look, it's fine. The original. The new one sucks.
Anyway here's the Moanas.
-
1 hr 29 min
Once More With(out) Dracula - Nosferatu (1922 & 2025)
Season 2, Episode 2
Show notes
Mariana and Gus watch an all timer and the everrare modern remake that’s…actually really good? You should watch both? What’s happening??
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 22 min
BONUS Once More With Punch Buggies, No Punch Backs - The Love Bug & Herbie: Fully Loaded (1969 & 2005)
Season 1, Episode 22
Show notes
Mariana and Gus watched two movies about a sentient car. Sentient cars?! What will they think of next? Sentient toys? Sentient bugs? Sentient fish? Sentient robots? Come on, Disney, that’d be pretty silly.
Support us!
Follow us!
IG
TikTok
Bluesky
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 24 min
Once More With Weird Frickin' Architecture - The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1920 & 2005)
Season 2, Episode 1
Show notes
In the SECOND SEASON PREMIER (woo!), Mariana and Gus watch one of the first ever horror movies ever, and also a weird like kinda remake "visual remix" thing? Dunno. Great start to the season. Love it.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 15 min
BONUS Once More With Robbers and Hairballs - That Darn Cat! (1965 & 1997)
Season 1, Episode 21
Show notes
Mariana and Gus watch a movie that, honestly, they first heard of like three weeks ago, then watch that movie's remake, which, again, honestly, was a kinda the nadir of 90s family comedies. Both of them have a cat in them. And robbers. Hence the episode title.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 36 min
BONUS Once More With Long-Lost Identical Twins - The Parent Trap (1961 & 1998)
Season 1, Episode 20
Show notes
You ever see two people who look exactly alike, except one is from Monterrey (Napa) and one is from Boston (London), and also they both have weird accents and are both allergic to accents and have the same freckles and eye color and hair cut? Gus and Mariana have because they watched The Parent Trap (1961) and The Parent Trap (1998) and that's basically the whole conceit of the film.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 46 min
BONUS Once More With Flying Rubber - The Absent-Minded Professor (1961) & Flubber (1997)
Season 1, Episode 19
Show notes
You know the deal by now. Mariana and Gus watch a movie from before times (1961's The Absent-Minded Professor) and from the less-before times (1997's Flubber) and then we talk about them and it was recorded and edited just for you. Nice.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 24 min
BONUS Once More With Great, Big, Shaggy Dogs - The Shaggy Dog (1959 & 2006)
Season 1, Episode 18
Show notes
Welcome to season 1.5 - live action Disney remakes of live action Disney movies! Join Mariana and Gus as they watch both The Shaggy Dogs and then talk about them. You know how this works by now.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 29 min
Once More With Once More With Feeling
Season 1, Episode 17
Show notes
Gus and Mariana look back on their Season 1 opinions, lessons, and Snow White Trauma.
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 57 min
Once More With Ohana, Which Means Family (w/ Yhara Zayd) - Lilo & Stitch (2002 & 2025)
Season 1, Episode 16
Show notes
Come listen to our SECOND EVER GUEST Yhara Zayd (@Yharazayd) talk with us about Lilo & Stitch. Ignore how unprepared and tired Gus is this episode. He was having a rough day, okay?
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
2 hr
Once More With YOU, Once More With Your COW - Mulan (1998 & 2020)
Season 1, Episode 15
Show notes
Mariana and Gus watched Gus' girlfriend's favorite Disney movie of all time - Mulan (1998), and also the international embarrassment that was Mulan (2020), and now they're gonna talk about it. Yay!
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
-
1 hr 43 min
Once More Without Worries For the Rest of Our Days - The Lion King (1994 & 2019)
Season 1, Episode 14
Show notes
Mariana and Gus watched one of Gus' favorite movies ever just for you - The Lion King (1994). And then, sadly, they also watched The Lion King (2019) because of the conceit of this podcast. And then they talked about it. And now it's here for your listening pleasure.
(The fan art Gus mentions in the episode)
Follow us!
Once More With Feeling is a podcast about great original movies and their often not-so-great remakes. Join film critic and YouTuber Mariana Colín (The Morbid Zoo) and screenwriter and comedian Gus Schiff as they explore the history, culture, and politics of some of Hollywood's favorite films to make over and over and over and over and over…
Music by: Isaiah Evans (@the_viennese_school)
Singing by: Sierra Lancaster (@_sierralancaster_)
Email: withfeelingpod@gmail.com
On these lists
Once More With Feeling is one of the shows picked out on this list
More in Film History
Placed highest on Apple Podcasts' Film History chart right now
