The Shock Treatment - A New York Football Giants podcast

🎙️ EPISODE 66 — DAVID DIEHL

The Giants are 4–2–1 and in FIRST PLACE in the NFC East! 🔵⚪️

A wild 27–21 OT win over Houston featuring JJ McCarthy continuing to grow, Malik Nabers doing Malik Nabers things, Skattebo running angry, a defense that answered the bell, and Singletary delivering the walk-off against his former team.

And yes… we need to talk about Zvada. 😤

After 14 years, the Giants are heading into November with a winning record and sitting on top of the division.

This feels different.

🎧 Listen to Episode 66 of The Shock Treatment wherever you get your podcasts.

#NYGiants #GiantsPride #BigBlue #TheShockTreatment #NFL #NFCe #InHarbaughWeTrust

The Shock Treatment — Episode 65: J.J. McCarthy: QB1

John Harbaugh has made the call.

J.J. McCarthy is officially QB1 for the Giants heading into Houston — and now it’s time to see what the kid can do.

In Episode 65, we break down the quarterback change, why I’m not buying the lazy “J.J. sucks” or “Jameis sucks” arguments, and why 10 NFL starts is nowhere near enough to decide what McCarthy ultimately becomes.

Adam Thielen’s endorsement of McCarthy’s deep ball gets us talking about what the young quarterback does well, what he still needs to develop, and one very simple message:

PUT THE BALL IN MALIK NABERS’ HANDS.

We also get into:

• Najee Harris and Jihad Ward being released • Harbaugh’s “iron fist” and the TAKE THE JOB mentality • Whether the Giants could be looking to add another running back • Who the hell is Jason Brownlee? • Malik Nabers absolutely cooking over the last three games • Jameis Winston remaining in the building and why we haven’t necessarily seen the last of him • Jaxson Dart’s role in the quarterback room • The full-circle storyline of McCarthy returning to Houston, where he won a national championship with Michigan • Malik Nabers vs. Marvin Harrison Jr. • Breaking down the Texans defense and whether their “great defense” is actually something to fear • The Giants sitting at 3-2-1 and somehow alone atop the NFC East

We’re not crowning J.J.

We’re not burying J.J.

We’re letting him play.

Because in the Harbaugh era:

YOU WANT THE JOB? TAKE THE JOB.

🎙️ The Shock Treatment — Episode 65 J.J. McCarthy: QB1

Episode 64: Jim Burt #64 — TOO LITTLE, TOO LATE

The New York Giants fall to the New Orleans Saints, 34–27, after digging themselves into a massive 34–10 hole before nearly pulling off an unbelievable comeback!

We’re breaking down the defensive collapse, the offensive struggles, and JJ McCarthy’s late-game push that brought Big Blue within striking distance. The comeback fell short on a fourth-down incompletion to Isaiah Likely, but did JJ show enough to change the quarterback conversation?

Plus, we discuss Jameis Winston’s future, the overblown narrative surrounding Cam Skattebo’s benching, John Harbaugh’s fiery exchanges with the media, and the emotional reaction from JJ’s teammates after the loss.

The Giants showed fight, but is that enough? Is this Jameis’ final chance to keep the starting job, or could JJ take over after the bye?

Too little, too late — or a glimpse of what’s possible?

Welcome to The Shock Treatment. Big Blue talk from two die-hard Giants fans. 🏈💙❤️

#NYGiants #GiantsPride #TheShockTreatment #BigBlue #NFL

🔥 EPISODE 63 — JIM CORDLE #63

We’re talking Giants vs. Saints ahead of Sunday’s matchup at MetLife — and why I’m feeling VERY confident about Big Blue coming out on top.

I also take a trip down memory lane and reminisce about my first-ever Giants game in person back in 2005… Giants vs. Saints. That experience helped create the football fanatic I am today, and it felt only right to bring that story into this episode.

Plus, the Jalen Hurts blood clot news throws a CRAZY monkey wrench into the NFC East. Hurts is officially out for Sunday against Carolina, and the Eagles are now dealing with an uncertain timeline at the most important position on the field. (Philadelphia Eagles⁠)

The Giants are sitting at 3-1-1, the Saints are 1-4, and I’m ready to see Big Blue take care of business.

LET THEM SLEEP.

🎙️ Episode 63 — Jim Cordle #63 💙❤️ The Shock Treatment — A New York Giants Podcast

#NYGiants #GiantsPride #BigBlue #NFL #GiantsVsSaints #ShockTreatment #NFCast #JalenHurts

⚡ EPISODE 62: GLENN PARKER — 3RD AND LIKELY! ⚡

The Giants and Washington finish in a wild 27–27 tie, and MtD is breaking it ALL down! Jameis Winston leads a furious comeback, Isaiah Likely explodes for two touchdowns, and Malik Nabers delivers when it matters most. But overtime heartbreak, missed opportunities, and a devastating Cam Skattebo fumble leave Big Blue searching for that finishing touch.

Plus, we discuss Jameis and Darnell Mooney’s viral sideline exchange, Dru Phillips and Arvell Reese making noise on defense, Marcus Mbow stepping up, and the Giants’ reported workout with pass rusher Yannick Ngakoue.

The Giants showed fight, but was this a point gained or a win thrown away? We’re 3–1–1 and still on top of the NFC East. Next stop: New Orleans!

🎙️ IN HARBAUGH WE TRUST. ON TO THE SAINTS!

#NYGiants #GiantsPride #TheShockTreatment #ThirdAndLikely #BigBlue

Episode 61 of The Shock Treatment — “Back On Top”

The Giants are 3-1 and alone in first place in the NFC East for the first time in nearly 4,000 days.

3-0 at home. Throwbacks on. LT ringing the bell.

Arvell Reese is a monster. The rookies are showing up. The culture has changed.

And Deonte Banks walks it off with a pick-six.

Jameis Winston delivers the full roller-coaster experience.

Haddy is home.

And we’re officially back on top of the division.

Let’s go Big Blue.

🔥 EPISODE 60 — SHAUN O’HARA: “ON TO ARIZONA” 🔥

Episode 60 is here.

This one is a little different. I say goodbye to Odell Beckham Jr., show him some love, and talk about what he meant to me and so many Giants fans. ❤️💙

But this is NOT the time to give up on the season. The Giants are 2-1, and there’s still plenty of football left to play.

We also briefly look ahead to Sunday’s matchup with the Cardinals and what I’m expecting from Big Blue.

We keep moving. On to Arizona.

🎙️ The Shock Treatment — A New York Football Giants Podcast

#NYGiants #GiantsNation #BigBlue #OdellBeckham #NFL #ShockTreatment #OnToArizona

🔥 EPISODE 59 — MICHAEL BOLEY

The Giants are 2-1 after a gritty 12-7 win over the Titans, and this felt like one of those games the old Giants would’ve found a way to lose.

But we didn’t.

We break down Jameis Winston’s first win, Skattebo, Zvada, Holland, Arvell Reese, the defense, and the Brian Burns injury.

And then, while we were recording…

🚨 THE GIANTS TRADED FOR J.J. MCCARTHY.

So yeah… we had to talk about that too. 😂

A crazy episode after a crazy week.

🎙️ The Shock Treatment — A New York Football Giants Podcast

#NYGiants #GiantsNation #BigBlue #JJMcCarthy #JameisWinston #ShockTreatment

Episode 58 of The Shock Treatment

Jaxson Dart’s season is over. Surgery is coming. It sucks.

But we’re not writing the kid’s story in September of Year 2.

He’s 23. He’s got time. We’ll be waiting for him.

In the meantime, it’s Jameis Winston’s show.

The roller coaster is here. Believe.

Andrew Thomas practiced.

We’re still 1-0 in the division.

Hit the reset button. The season starts Sunday against the Titans.

Let’s go Big Blue.

THE SHOCK TREATMENT — EMERGENCY POD EPISODE 57.5

The news Giants fans were hoping we wouldn’t hear.

Further testing has revealed that Jaxson Dart’s knee injury is worse than initially believed, with reports that season-ending surgery is now a possibility.

In this emergency episode, we talk about the latest developments, what this could mean for Dart and the Giants, Jameis Winston potentially taking over at quarterback, and the brutal reality of how quickly the outlook for this 2026 season can change.

Nothing has been officially finalized yet.

But damn…

This one hurts.

Please be okay, Jaxson. 💙

THE SHOCK TREATMENT — EPISODE 57

CHASE BLACKBURN — “PLEASE BE OK, JAXSON”

Well, Giants fans… that fucking sucked.

The Giants get blown out by the Rams 28-6 on Monday Night Football, but the final score almost feels secondary after Jaxson Dart left the game with a knee injury on the opening drive.

In Episode 57, we break down the ugly loss, the latest on Dart as we await his MRI, Jameis Winston being thrown into the game unexpectedly, and the brutal team statistics that tell the story of just how badly the Giants were outplayed.

We talk 481 yards allowed, 182 yards gained, a 3.3 yards-per-play average, the Rams’ dominant rushing attack, Davante Adams’ monster night, Aaron Donald’s return, and a running game that couldn’t get going.

But it’s not all negative.

We give flowers to Jevon Holland for his two interceptions and forced fumble, Abdul Carter for his first NFL sack, and talk about how this Giants team responds when adversity finally hits.

We also pay our respects to Ernie Accorsi, reflect on what this franchise has meant across generations, and look ahead to the Titans coming to MetLife.

The Giants are 1-1.

The loss was ugly.

The injuries are concerning.

But the season isn’t over.

Now we find out what this team is made of.

Most importantly: PLEASE BE OKAY, JAXSON.

🎙️ The Shock Treatment 🏈 A New York Football Giants Podcast

THE SHOCK TREATMENT — EPISODE 56

“THE GOAT” 🐐

The Giants are 1-0, and Episode 56 is LOADED.

We break down the 28-20 Sunday Night Football victory over Dallas, starting with the poise and command of Jaxson Dart in his regular-season debut. 23/29, 230 yards, 3 TD, 0 INT — and a Giants offense that converted 9 of its first 10 third downs.

We talk about the new identity of this football team — physical, aggressive, accountable and ready to punch back.

👀 Najee Harris potentially making his Giants debut 🏃‍♂️ Why this running back room is giving us shades of 2007 💙 Malik Nabers getting his first regular-season catch 🧱 Andrew Thomas appreciation ⚡ The Giants’ defense rallying around Dart after the sideline hit 🛡️ Maybe I spoke too soon about the cornerback room? 👀 Paulson Adebo to IR 📉 The Daboll vs. Harbaugh contrast 🐐 Lawrence Taylor and why Episode 56 belongs to the GOAT

Then we turn the page to Monday Night Football in Los Angeles.

Aaron Donald is potentially returning. Puka Nacua. Davante Adams. Matthew Stafford. Sean McVay.

Can Jaxson Dart do it again? Can the Giants’ running game travel? Can this defense handle the Rams’ weapons?

The Giants are 1-0.

Now let’s see if this new-look Giants team can prove it wasn’t a fluke.

The Shock Treatment — Episode 56.

Week 1. Giants 28, Cowboys 20. The Hardbaugh era starts with a W.

On this episode of The Shock Treatment:

• OBJ’s blonde hair is back, MetLife popped, Cruz, Rolle, Tuck, and LT in the building

• Nabers active and involved — first catch is a mental win

• Dallas 3-and-out to open, Giants defer, then punch them in the mouth on the ground

• Skattebo TD (lose the backflip), then Singletary finishes a clock-killer drive

• Isaiah Likely is the steal of the offseason — wide-open TD, another TD, “3rd and Likely”

• Dart processing fast, taking hits, getting everyone the ball

• Defense has juice under Dennard Wilson — Holland pick after the Tracy fumble

• Refs, Adebo on specials, Banks/Newsome banged up, and why Joey Porter Jr. is a name to watch

• Mara hands Harbaugh the game ball

• Nagy + Roman actually looks like a real offense

Big Blue talk. Real talk. Go Big Blue.

EPISODE 54 — THERE’S NO PLACE LIKE HOME

The 2026 regular season is finally here, and the New York Giants are heading into Week 1 with a completely different feel around the organization.

Michael breaks down the Giants’ final 53-man roster and compares it to his own preseason projection — and somehow went 49-for-53 for a 92.5% hit rate.

Then there’s the biggest story of all: Odell Beckham Jr. is officially back with the Giants. We talk about what his return means, why he earned his roster spot, the leadership he brings to Malik Nabers and Jaxson Dart, and why OBJ doesn’t need to be the same player he was in 2014 to make an impact.

And because this is the Giants, the breaking news didn’t stop while we were recording…

🚨 Jameis Winston signs a 2-year extension 🚨 Jon Runyan Jr. signs a 2-year, $22 million extension 🚨 Darius Slayton is released just six days before the season opener

We also dive into John Harbaugh’s new culture, Isaiah Likely’s eye-opening comments about the changes inside the building, Cam Skattebo’s expected workload, the massive changes to the linebacker room, the defensive line concerns, Jaxson Dart’s supporting cast and what we need to see when the Giants take on the Dallas Cowboys.

The new era is here.

Giants football is back.

And as always…

There’s no place like home. 🏠⚡️

🎙️ The Shock Treatment — Episode 54

Shock Treatment Episode 53 — “Harry Carson”

The preseason is officially heating up, and the Giants just put together a 26–3 statement win over the Miami Dolphins. MTD breaks down Jameis Winston’s impressive performance, a defense playing with a completely different edge, Greg Newsome and Chauncey Golston making their presence felt, and rookie JC Davis earning major praise after playing every snap at left tackle.

We also dive deep into the 53-man roster projection, the crowded WR room, Odell Beckham Jr.’s heartbreaking end-zone drop, the Calvin Austin injury, the Josh Ezeudu trade, and what could be next before final cuts.

Giants dominated the Dolphins in joint practice as we get ready for Saturday’s preseason matchup! We break down Jaxson Dart’s continued growth, his developing chemistry with Isaiah Likely, and why Likely could quickly become his security blanket.

We also get into the joint-practice brawl, Abdul Carter, Jameis Winston, Jermaine Eluemunor and why both teams are clearly ready to hit somebody other than their own teammates! 😂

Plus: OBJ’s fight to make the roster, Najee Harris signing, the JuJu cut, Jordan Stout’s emergence, Brian Burns setting the tone, Malik Nabers’ return, and the ongoing Jaxson Dart blue-tent saga! 😂

And of course, we preview Giants vs. Dolphins!

🔥 Episode 52 is LIVE!

#ShockTreatment #NYGiants #BigBlue #JaxsonDart #OBJ #IsaiahLikely #AbdulCarter #GiantsNation

The New York Giants are officially back on the field, and MTD is locked in! Episode 51 breaks down the Giants’ preseason opener against Minnesota, Jaxson Dart’s performance, the emergence of Arvell Reese and Tremaine Edmunds, the continued development of a young Giants defense, Malik Nabers’ road back to Week 1, and the latest roster moves — including the Giants’ interest in Najee Harris.

And of course… OBJ IS BACK HOME. MTD dives into Odell Beckham Jr.’s return, his battle to earn a roster spot, and why seeing him back in Giants blue means so much. Plus, a look ahead at what’s next for John Harbaugh’s new-look Giants.

The Giants are back. Football is back. And so is Shock Treatment. 💙🏈⚡️

MTD reacts to the OBJ return, breaks down the latest roster moves, and covers all the recent Big Blue news as the offseason continues!

Episode 49 of Shock Treatment covers all the latest Giants free agency news, trade rumors, and roster moves as the offseason heats up. We break down what it means for the future of Big Blue under John Harbaugh and preview what’s ahead with the NFL Draft around the corner.

The Giants are building something.

This week we break down the full coaching overhaul — Matt Nagy hired as OC, Dennard Wilson takes over the defense after helping build the NFL’s #1 pass unit in Philly, and Chris Horton brings Ravens special teams toughness to Big Blue.

We also dive into the Steve Tisch/Epstein controversy, former Giants all over Super Bowl 60, and of course… an Eli Manning Hall of Fame rant you don’t want to miss.

In Harbaugh we trust.

Shock Treatment.

MtD.

#Giants #NFL #BigBlue