Podcast

The Untapped New York Podcast

History, Places & Travel, Society & Culture

The Untapped New York Podcast is an award-winning podcast about New York City’s secrets, like how does a water tower work? Why does steam come out of the ground? Do alligators live in the subway? We impart our knowledge, interview experts, and in many cases, literally go behind the scenes. The Untapped New York Podcast was the 2025 GANYC Apple Award winner for Outstanding Achievement in NYC Radio Program or Podcast. Hosted by Michelle Young, founder, and Justin Rivers, Chief Experience Officer, at Untapped New York.

Places & Travel chart
#184
Episodes
37
Releases
Every two weeks
Typical length
35 min
On air since
2023
Latest episode
1 day ago

Episodes

37 episodes, newest first

  1. The Gilded Age Show Returns! A Sneak Peek at Season 4

    Season 5, Episode 5

    Show notes

    Untapped New York got a sneak peak of the new season of The Gilded Age which premiered on November 1st! Michelle and Nicole discuss the real-life filming locations, recap the dramatic events of season 3, what happened in the first episode of season 4, some celebrity cameos, and tease what's to come. For even more Gilded Age join us on our related tours: Fifth Avenue Gilded Age Mansions tour, the Gilded Age Met Museum Tour: Art & Ambition, and Gilded Age Wealth and Power: Midtown tour.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    19 min
  2. NYC's Newest Waterfront Art

    Season 5, Episode 4

    Show notes

    New York Harbor is the largest open-air museum in the world and almost nobody has curated it. Join Michelle and Justin as they talk about the newest art installations and highlights from our newest boat tour, The Unframed City, which treats 400 years of waterfront as a single, navigable exhibition space.

    Music by Kittens Ablaze.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    36 min
  3. Pop! into the Secret Brooklyn Bridge Champagne Vaults

    Season 5, Episode 3

    Show notes

    In celebration of our new partnership with Apple Podcasts, we're re-releasing one of our favorite episodes about the secret champagne vaults in the Brooklyn Bridge! The location is now part of Apple's Hidden Histories Guides to New York City.

    If you haven't heard of this delicious tidbit, you're in for a ride through a bygone New York. If you do know about it, Michelle and Justin from Untapped New York are sharing additional insider secrets about this subject that are not publicly known, or have ever been written about. Cheers!

    Music by Kittens Ablaze.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    38 min
  4. The Macy's Bag Disappears from 34th Street

    Season 5, Episode 2

    Show notes

    One of the biggest piece of news, at least for us urban nerds, is that the iconic, oversized Macy's bag that has long been on the corner of 34th Street at Herald Square is gone. There was no notice. Where did it go? What's going to happen? Michelle and Justin from Untapped New York talk about the history of the "Million Dollar Corner," how the kitschy shopping bag came to be, and what's coming next for that tiny piece of property next to Macy's, along with other holdout buildings to look out for in New York City!

    Music in the episode by Kittens Ablaze.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    34 min
  5. 9/11: 25 Years Later

    Season 5, Episode 1

    Show notes

    Welcome to the new season of The Untapped New York Podcast! On the 25th anniversary of 9/11, the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Twin Towers in New York City, Michelle and Justin from Untapped New York share their memories of that day, the history of rebuilding the site, and the impact on the city since. Justin was a brand new elementary school teacher, four days into the job, when the attack unfolded through the windows of his school on the Lower East Side.

    Music in the episode by Kittens Ablaze.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    35 min
  6. The Art Curator Who Outsmarted the Nazis

    Season 4, Episode 10

    Show notes

    Today we’re rereleasing a live conversation about Untapped New York founder Michelle Young's award-winning book, The Art Spy: The Extraordinary Untold Tale of WWII Resistance Hero Rose Valland, in honor of its paperback release this week. The Art Spy was named a Best Book of 2025 by the New York Public Library, Library Journal, and Hyperallergic, and named the 2026 Massachusetts Book Awards Nonfiction Honors Title.

    Michelle and our Chief Experience Officer, Justin Rivers, delve into who Rose Valland was and the brave things she did, the story of Jewish art dealer Paul Rosenberg and his family, which allowed Michelle to write about her first love, New York City, and Rosenberg's clients including characters like Pablo Picasso and Henri Matisse. There’s also a wild World’s Fair connection in the book.

    Listen to the original episode: "A WWII Resistance Spy and Her NYC Connections" to hear Michelle read the first chapter of the book.

    Music by Kittens Ablaze.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    mosaic: Exploring Jewish Issues

    mosaic is Jewish Federation of Palm Beach County's news magazine show, exploring...

    Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

    52 min
  7. Heists at the Met Museum

    Season 4, Episode 9

    Show notes

    If you're following the heist at the Louvre, discover the heists that have occurred at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City, including the infamous "Valentine's Day Heist" of 1979! Untapped New York founder Michelle Young talks with Nicole Saraniero, our editor and director of events who wrote the article, "10 Major Art Heists at the Met Museum."

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    16 min
  8. NYC Secrets: The Barthman Clock Beneath Your Feet

    Season 4, Episode 8

    Show notes

    Maybe you saw our latest Instagram reel that's going viral, making NYC horological history cool again! On the podcast, in honor of fall back time this week, we deep dive into the Barthman clock, a historic clock beneath your feet in the Financial District. Michelle, Justin and Nicole talk about the history of the clock, share their experience going down into the secret room/basement underneath the clock, and more!

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    16 min
  9. Secrets of Grand Central: Find the Hidden Mural in the Wine Shop

    Season 4, Episode 7

    Show notes

    Did you know there's a mini version of Grand Central's ceiling mural inside the terminal's wine shop, Central Cellars? And that it used to be part of a movie theater? We talk to the experts: the authors of a book about the artist who did the painting, the passionate and informed store manager and employees, and historian Justin Rivers, Untapped New York's Chief Experience Officer who perfected our Secrets of Grand Central tour.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    13 min
  10. Secrets of Morningside Heights

    Season 4, Episode 6

    Show notes

    Michelle Young and Justin Rivers of Untapped New York discuss the neighborhood of Morningside Heights. Michelle and Justin will discuss five hidden and unique spots including Columbia University's Alma Mater, the Guastavino Dome at the Cathedral of St. John the Divine, Riverside Church’s Labyrinth, Ulysses S. Grant’s Tomb, and the meeting of 125th and 129th Streets.

    This podcast episode was originally produced in partnership with Columbia University Graduate School of Architecture Planning and Preservation (GSAPP), where Michelle Young is a Professor of Architecture and an alumni of the school with a master degree in Urban Planning.

    Music by Kittens Ablaze.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    37 min
  11. World's Fair Mosaics Removed from Flushing Meadows-Corona Park!

    Season 4, Episode 5

    Show notes

    Sad news from Queens...After multiple patchwork repairs, a set of colorful mosaics depicting highlights from the 1939-40 and 1964-65 World's Fairs have been completely replaced with pavers. Michelle, Justin and Nicole discuss this piece of very sad news, broken by Untapped New York and the most read article this month so far. The Passarelle Plaza mosaics were installed in 1997 to commemorate the 1939-40 and 1964-65 World's Fairs. Now, they are another lost relic of World's Fair history.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    25 min
  12. Pandas in NYC, Oh My!

    Season 4, Episode 4

    Show notes

    In this episode, we’re talking about a very adorable secret: pandas in New York City! Who doesn’t love pandas? In fact, the story of how pandas came to America is deeply tied to New York City. We're joined by an expert on this story, Nathalia Holt, author of The Beast in the Clouds: The Roosevelt Brothers' Deadly Quest to Find the Mythical Giant Panda. Learn the New York City origin story behind the discovery of the panda, about Theodore Roosevelt and his sons in Prohibition Era New York, all the pandas who have graced the Big Apple with their presence over the years, the first American (a woman!) to bring back a panda cub from China, and the passionate attempts to bring pandas back in recent years by some very notable New Yorkers.

    Correction: When the podcast episode refers to Hyde Park, it should be Sagamore Hill.

    Music by Kittens Ablaze.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    mosaic: Exploring Jewish Issues

    mosaic is Jewish Federation of Palm Beach County's news magazine show, exploring...

    Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

    40 min
  13. The Champagne Vaults in the Brooklyn Bridge

    Season 4, Episode 3

    Show notes

    We delve into one of our favorite New York City secrets: the champagne and wine vaults inside the Brooklyn Bridge. If you haven't heard of this delicious tidbit, you're in for a ride through a bygone New York. If you do know about it, Michelle and Justin from Untapped New York are sharing additional insider secrets about this subject that are not publicly known, or have ever been written about. Cheers!

    (01:25) Brooklyn Bridge

    Music by Kittens Ablaze.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    35 min
  14. A WWII Resistance Spy and Her NYC Connections

    Season 4, Episode 2

    Show notes

    A conversation between Michelle Young, Untapped New York's founder and Justin Rivers, our Chief Experience Officer, about Michelle's newest book, The Art Spy: The Extraordinary Untold Tale of WWII Resistance Hero Rose Valland. Michelle and Justin delve into who Rose Valland was and the brave things she did, the story of Jewish art dealer Paul Rosenberg and his family, which allowed Michelle to write about her first love, New York City, and Rosenberg's clients including characters like Pablo Picasso and Henri Matisse. There’s also a wild World’s Fair connection in the book.

    Music by Kittens Ablaze. Additional music by Mykola Sosin from Pixabay.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    mosaic: Exploring Jewish Issues

    mosaic is Jewish Federation of Palm Beach County's news magazine show, exploring...

    Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

    56 min
  15. Amelia Earhart's NYC Haunts

    Season 4, Episode 1

    Show notes

    We’re kicking off season 4 of the Untapped New York Podcast with New York City literary sensation, Laurie Gwen Shapiro, whose newest book The Aviator and the Showman, just came out about Amelia Earhart’s marriage with publisher George Putnam, which set her on a collision course with fate. Because we’re a New York City obsessed podcast, we’ll be talking with Laurie about all of Amelia’s New York City connections (there are many!)—from studying at Columbia, riding the subway, and eating Chinese food, to meeting Putnam at the center of the Jazz Age publishing world in Midtown Manhattan, and more.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    mosaic: Exploring Jewish Issues

    mosaic is Jewish Federation of Palm Beach County's news magazine show, exploring...

    Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

    43 min
  16. Why is the FDR Drive Purple?

    Season 3, Episode 7

    Show notes

    In the latest episode of the Untapped New York Podcast, Michelle Young, author, journalist, and the founder of Untapped New York, tracks down the answer to her latest burning question about New York City: Why is the FDR Drive Purple? If you’ve been wondering or…have yet to notice, prepare to have your mind blown. A lot of myths abound, none of them true.

    No, the New York State D.O.T. did not just happen to have a ton of extra purple paint. It's also not inspired by the color of someone's tie in New York City government. And the color choice wasn't an accident but how it looks today is not how it was intended.

    To get down to the root of it, Michelle went to the source and interviewed Gregg Pasquarelli, founding partner at ShoP Architects and Cathy Jones, project director at SHoP, who designed the Master Plan for the East River Waterfront. They have the definitive answer on the unusual pastel color choice, and also what has gone wrong. The trio also spoke about all things FDR Drive—including all the films that have been shot there.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    31 min
  17. A Harrowing Tale of NYPD Corruption, the Mafia and Murder

    Season 3, Episode 6

    Show notes

    The new book The Blood and the Badge, by former New York Times editor Michael Cannell, chronicles a true tale of police corruption, mafia, and murderous mayhem in 1980s New York City. Nicholas Pileggi, author of Wiseguy describes the book as a “harrowing story...Cannell misses nothing." In our latest episode of the Untapped New York podcast, Untapped New York founder Michelle Young (the author of the forthcoming book The Art Spy) talks with Cannell about the crazier than fiction story.

    The Blood and the Badge unpacks the rise and fall of two NYPD detectives, Louis Eppolito and Stephen Caracappa, who ended up on the mafia payroll for decades. Eppolito, whom Cannell describes as a "loud, boorish, vulgar guy," and a "loose cannon," came from a mafia family and initially rejected a life of crime but gradually came back to the other side. Caracappa was the polar opposite of Eppolito and truly cold-blooded. The two leave behind a wake of deaths and destruction, and almost get away with it all. In our podcast episode, Michelle also shares her unexpected personal connection to some characters in The Blood and the Badge.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    28 min
  18. The Stolen Queen: A Mystery Whodunnit Set in the Met Museum

    Season 3, Episode 5

    Show notes

    The Stolen Queen, the newest historical fiction novel by New York Times bestselling author Fiona Davis, publishes today, January 7, and is set in the hallowed halls of the Metropolitan Museum of Art. When the Met’s prized Egyptian artifact goes missing, an unlikely female duo—curator and anthropologist Charlotte Cross and eighteen-year-old Annie Jenkins from the Met’s costume department—team up to investigate the theft, unraveling decades old secrets particularly in Charlotte’s own past. Charlotte is an enigmatic figure, and Annie is peppy, indefatigable young woman at the start of her career. Fiona Davis describes The Stolen Queen as "mummies and glamour."

    Here at Untapped New York, we're kicking off 2025 with a new podcast episode featuring Fiona in conversation with our founder, Michelle Young whose own narrative non-fiction book The Art Spy: The Extraordinary Untold Tale of WWII Resistance Spy Rose Valland publishes in May.

    Other books mentioned in the podcast include Patrick Bringley's All the Beauty in the World, and Lynne Olson's Empress of the Nile.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    25 min
  19. Secret New York: An Unusual Guide

    Season 3, Episode 4

    Show notes

    The newest edition of Secret New York, An Unusual Guide, is out! Michelle Young, founder of Untapped New York and author of "Secret New York," interviews her co-author Hannah Frishberg, a native New Yorker and arts and culture reporter with Gothamist/WNYC. Discover some of the exciting new entries in the guidebook, including the IFC Center's spy holes, the Hess Triangle, a section of the Berlin Wall, and two quirky lighthouses in the Bronx and Staten Island. They also highlight the Red Room at One Wall Street, set to reopen in the spring. Michelle and Hannah also kick off our newest series, "Meet a New Yorker"!

    Get an autographed copy of Secret New York, An Unusual Guide!

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    21 min
  20. Take the 5: The Pets of NYC

    Season 3, Episode 3

    Show notes

    This week's "Take the 5" podcast episode is all about the pets and animals of New York City. We recorded the episode on Election Day, not knowing who would become President. But regardless of the outcome at the time, we hoped it will be a respite from political news for all of you!

    Michelle, Justin, and Nicole talk about the new Pets of NYC exhibition at New York Historical, the former Canine Chief of Engine 203, the euthanization of squirrel Instagram star, Peanut, and more. We even have an audio reading from Peggy Gavan, author of the The Bravest Pets of Gotham: Tales of Four-Legged Firefighters of Old New York. Michelle also talks about her experience when rats moved into her car during the pandemic.

    Our goal at Untapped New York is to surprise lifelong New Yorkers, so we keep digging until we find the story you've never heard, the hidden gems you've never seen. Think of the tennis court hidden above Grand Central, the abandoned subway stations under your feet, or the scandals inside 5th Ave's Gilded Age mansions. Go to untappednewyorktours to discover dozens of small group walking tours, all led by local guides who love th

    17 min