Podcast
What Would Jessica Do: A Murder, She Wrote Podcast
A Murder, She Wrote rewatch podcast featuring a clinical psychologist and a fallen artist with opinions on everything. Dr. Sarah and Caroline break down classic episodes of the 80s mystery show, connect each one to a real-life true-crime case, and answer listener problems with one question: What would Jessica do? Expect cat updates, twin tween chaos, real psychology, and a lot of laughing. For mystery fans, true crime fans, and anyone who wants to hang out with two women who crack each other up.
New episodes every two weeks.
- Episodes
- 2
- Releases
- Every two weeks
- Typical length
- 42 min
- On air since
- 2026
- Latest episode
- 1 week ago
Episodes
2 episodes, newest first
-
38 min
To the Last Will I Grapple with Thee (Happy Birthday, Angela!)
Season 8, Episode 17
Show notes
Jessica spends her birthday at an Irish pub in New York, and of course someone turns up dead.
It's Angela Lansbury's birthday week, so we picked the episode where it's Jessica's birthday too (Season 8, "To the Last Will I Grapple with Thee"). Sarah breaks down the kind of rage and obsession behind a death that isn't what it looks like and traces the trick back to a Sherlock Holmes story. Caroline counts the terrible Irish accents, catches Jessica flirting with the detective over Melville quotes, and finds a real case with a twist straight out of the episode. Plus, the twins go exploring in a sewer, a measuring cup gets a new job, and we decide whether Jessica would ever join Facebook.
Content note: this episode includes discussion of suicide. If you're struggling, you can call or text 988 (in the US) anytime.
New here? Start with Episode 1, “Old Habits Die Hard”: https://spotifycreators-web.app.link/e/il1N2HTHx7b
Follow the show so Episode 3 lands in your feed the day it drops.
🎵 Theme Music: "In Death We Type" composed by Bryan Hillebrandt. Check out more of his work at https://bryhill.bandcamp.com/
-
46 min
Old Habits Die Hard: A Nun, a Murder, and Jessica’s Sorority Sister
Season 1, Episode 1
Show notes
Jessica should be home finishing her book. Instead, she stays at a convent to help an old sorority sister solve a nun’s murder.
The episode aired 39 years ago today, so we’re celebrating its anniversary properly. Sarah explains the psychology of who does this kind of thing and why. Then we get into a real convent murder: the case of Sister Abhaya in India, which took 28 years to solve. Somewhere along the way, we start guessing what period products Jessica would buy, and Caroline proposes shutting down the world for one day to teach men about women’s bodies. (She only needs four hours, tops.)
Hit follow so Episode 2 shows up in your feed the day it drops.
🎵 Theme Music: "In Death We Type" composed by Bryan Hillebrandt. Check out more of his work at https://bryhill.bandcamp.com/
TV Reviews lists
More TV Reviews shows picked out from the charts
More in TV Reviews
Placed highest on Apple Podcasts' TV Reviews chart right now